Is the Fox Guarding the Hen House?
- Announcements
- Branch Transformation
Categories:
“Very cool.” “Incredible!” “This doesn’t look like a bank.”
Showing the world that a traditional bank doesn’t have to feel like one, today’s financial institutions are finding new ways to wow customers. So much so, it seems like the “design” in most building plans should come first and foremost. To that we say, “slow your roll.”
How to build a better bank.
Actually, maybe the statement should be revised to “How to build a bank better.” In its simplest terms, every branch or main office project has an owner, a designer and a general contractor. From there are two models to compare:
- Design-Bid-Build (aka “Old School”) – This is the traditional model, where the architect and builder are separate. The architect creates a set of blueprints independent of the contractor. It’s on the owner to submit bids and determine who is right for the project.
- Design-Build (aka “New School”) – The more modern approach. This is where the owner hires one firm to be responsible for design and construction. This model maximizes value (Download White Paper) and eliminates the owner as the middle man.
Two kinds of Design-Builders
1 – In-House Design (Design Led) – Not all design-builders are the same. Some have design in-house and others don’t. Firms with in-house designers (on staff) lead with design, and not construction. For banks and credit unions this can introduce risk into the equation – especially when cost is king. Risk is not starting the project with a budget. Risk is using the same designers for all projects. Risk is more costly projects.
All firms charge their client overhead costs. Overhead of the business (indirect overhead), which would include costly designers, as well as direct overhead for the project (cost to do the work). These firms also charge a design fee. Sounds a lot like the Fox is now “in” the Hen House.
2 – Out-Source Design (Construction Led) – Design-builders who outsource design are construction led firms. Research shows less than 15% of the total cost of a branch is branding, furniture, fixtures and equipment. So, the key cost buckets are the non-sexy components that no one sees.
By outsourcing design, the cost of the project is lower. Only the cost of the designer (design fee) is assigned to the project. So, there is no double-dip on overhead and design fee. Moreover, by leading with construction, the budget for the project is preserved. The budget is the north star and is what defines what happens next. In this way, designers can be free (freed knowing the budget) to create “beginning with the end in mind”.
Beware of Wolves in Sheep’s Clothing
Jim Collins in his revolutionary book “Good to Great” characterized great companies as those that focus on their hedgehog concept. Few design-builders, who specialize in banks and credit unions, grew up in construction – it is not their hedgehog. Some of these firms grew up as bank equipment firms, others focus on branding, and nearly all lead with design aesthetic. These firms are not vanguards of budget and branch performance, because it is not in their DNA. They cannot offer what they don’t have.
At LEVEL5, we are a construction-led design-build firm who incorporates data, local market knowledge, and expert site selection to maximize your return on investment. We understand that lowering risk is in on the minds of banks and credit unions night and day.
